8d · 12-Mark Comparison Questions

🎯 Section C · Mini Site 8d

12-Mark Comparison Questions

Two works, one production feature, similarities and differences. The highest-level thinking on the paper — side-by-side analysis across the repertoire.

1
per paper
12
marks
~13
mins suggested

📚 What you'll learn on this page

  • Recognise a comparison question and the six possible linking words (similarities, differences, contrast, enhance, appreciation)
  • Structure your answer using the Similarities → Differences framework with DLIE depth
  • Use comparison connectives (similarly, in contrast, however, whereas) to signpost the examiner through your thinking
  • Compare all six works across 8 key features — costume, lighting, aural, set, intent, stimulus, mood, choreographic content
  • Pick any two works and see them side-by-side in the Works Explorer
  • Work through a bank of 10 exam-style questions with mark-scheme model answers
Exam Technique

A 12-mark comparison question always names two works, one production feature, and asks you to discuss similarities and differences. The wording is almost identical every year:

The standard wording
Standard
Using your knowledge of the similarities and differences in the [feature] used in [Work A] and [Work B], discuss how [feature] is used to enhance our appreciation of these two works. [12 marks]

Three example questions, showing the pattern:

Costume
Using your knowledge of the similarities and differences in the costumes used in Infra and Shadows, discuss how costume is used to enhance our appreciation of these two works.
12 mk
Aural
Using your knowledge of the similarities and differences in the aural setting used in Emancipation of Expressionism and Shadows, discuss how the aural setting is used to enhance our appreciation of these two works.
12 mk
Set
Using your knowledge of the similarities and differences in the staging/set used in Within Her Eyes and Infra, discuss how staging/set is used to enhance our appreciation of these two works. You may refer to props in your answer.
12 mk
👁️
Examiner's EyeYou need to address both works and cover similarities and differences. Answers that only discuss one work in depth, or that only list differences, cannot reach Level 4. The word "discuss" tells you interpretation and evaluation are still expected — this isn't a list.
Comparison Tables — All 6 Works Side by Side

Use these tables as your revision foundation. Pick any feature, see all six works in one place. The spotting similarities and differences is half the work done for any comparison question.

🎯 Choreographic Intention — what the choreographer wanted the work to express. This is often the link point in 12-mark questions.
ATArtificial Things
To explore life's limitations and the resolutions to these. To explore being the subject of other people's gaze.
ALCA Linha Curva
To celebrate Brazilian culture — samba, capoeira, carnival, the way Brazilian men show off, compete and communicate.
EofEEmancipation of Expressionism
Hip hop as a means of emancipation — showing hip hop can be elevated and expressive like any other dance form.
InfraInfra
Emotional life below the surface of city streets — the private turmoil hidden beneath the anonymous public face.
ShadShadows
A small family facing an unknown outside force, inspired by WWII families living in fear of an unseen threat.
WHEWithin Her Eyes
A love story with a twist — exploring loss, dependency, loyalty and grief through intense physical contact.
💡 Stimulus — what inspired the choreographer to make the work. Can be an image, a text, a place, a personal memory, a piece of music.
ATArtificial Things
A snow globe with a figure on a collapsed wheelchair. Paintings by Goran Djurovic (Unknown Secrets). The dancers' own life experiences.
ALCA Linha Curva
Brazilian culture — samba, capoeira, carnival. Galili's experience working with Brazilian dancers.
EofEEmancipation of Expressionism
Kenrick "H2O" Sandy's personal journey in dance. The potential of hip hop as a vehicle for emancipation and expression.
InfraInfra
T.S. Eliot's The Waste Land — the crowd flowing over London Bridge. Also the 2005 London Bombings on the Underground.
ShadShadows
WWII families living in hiding or fleeing — the refugee experience, fear of an unseen external threat.
WHEWithin Her Eyes
A commission brief: A Love Story with a Twist. Cousins' exploration of contact work and physical dependency.
🎭 Mood & Atmosphere — the emotional feeling the audience gets. Often shifts across a work.
ATArtificial Things
Cold, isolated, contemplative → warm, resolved. A sense of melancholy and nostalgia runs throughout.
ALCA Linha Curva
Energetic, joyful, competitive, sensual. High-octane celebration, with quieter moments in the Adage Septet.
EofEEmancipation of Expressionism
Mystical → urban → contemplative → climactic release. Builds from confined to liberated.
InfraInfra
Intimate, raw, melancholy. A sense of private emotion within urban anonymity.
ShadShadows
Fearful, tense, tragic → dignified acceptance. A sense of impending doom lifting into quiet resignation.
WHEWithin Her Eyes
Ethereal, haunting, tender. A sense of something unresolved or otherworldly.
👕 Costume — colour, style, era, material, and how it supports character and intent.
ATArtificial Things
Muted blues, greens and beige with a distinctive streaked dip-dye paint effect. Different eras — Amy's 1960s dress, Laura's 1940s trousers, men's modern-day. Dave's brown jacket recalls his father. Designer: Anna Jones.
ALCA Linha Curva
Men in coloured shorts with metallic discs, bare chests. Women in bright bikini tops and shorts in coral, orange, pink. Vibrant carnival palette.
EofEEmancipation of Expressionism
Functional streetwear — loose trousers, earthy t-shirts in pale blues, black, grey. Hi-top trainers. The typical hip-hop "crew" look, stripped back and minimal.
InfraInfra
Fitted shorts, vests and t-shirts in flesh, black, white and grey. Females in pointe shoes. LED figures on screen wear public overcoats, briefcases, pencil skirts. Designer: Moritz Junge.
ShadShadows
Individual 1940s character costumes — Mother's floral tea dress, Father's collarless shirt and waistcoat, Son's untucked shirt, Daughter's grey skirt and cotton blouse. Oversized overcoats at the end.
WHEWithin Her Eyes
F: sheer cream chiffon blouse buttoned high, skirt, bare feet. Cardigan at start. Top 2 buttons come undone later. M: dark khaki chinos, long-sleeved sweatshirt, khaki boots.
🏛️ Set & Props — the staging environment, scenery, objects used on stage or on screen.
ATArtificial Things
Snow-globe-shaped wooden border on pale grey floor. Vitrine on its side USL filled with snow. Headless mannequin in brown suit on 3 stools. Collapsed wheelchair DSR. Linear pathways of paper snow. Painted backcloth.
ALCA Linha Curva
Bare stage — no scenery. Open space to maximise visibility of 28 dancers. Some props (skateboards) in the Skateboard section.
EofEEmancipation of Expressionism
Minimal black box. A black backdrop that flies out to reveal a white cyclorama in the climactic final section. No other scenery.
InfraInfra
18m LED screen suspended high upstage with white electronic walking figures. Black box below with no other scenery. Set designer: Julian Opie.
ShadShadows
Minimal — table, bench, 2 stools, coat stand USL with worn coats and suitcases from the very start. Black surrounding space.
WHEWithin Her Eyes
No theatrical set. Site-sensitive Welsh landscape — deserted street, open field, forest, heath, quarry, cliff top.
💡 Lighting — colour, intensity, direction, patterns. Supports mood, shape and time of day.
ATArtificial Things
Cold white spots creating snow-globe pools. Cold blue wash in Gliding Trio. Warm amber sidelight SL for Family Portraits. Journey from cold/dark to warm/resolved.
ALCA Linha Curva
49 overhead lights in a 7×7 chequerboard grid in multiple colours, pre-programmed to change. Warm orange sidelighting in Battle. Drops to 7 yellow squares in Adage Septet. Designer: Itzik Galili.
EofEEmancipation of Expressionism
Prominent blue wash from above. White sidelights from SR in Section 2. Theatrical fog catches the blue light. Pale purple cyclorama reveal at the climax.
InfraInfra
3 mid-intensity white pools DS in a horizontal line. 6 rectangles of white light encase 6 duets. Deep blue beams and stark white sidelighting later. Blurred, hazy edges.
ShadShadows
Naturalistic domestic feel. Cold white sidelighting for tense sections, warmer interior lights for family moments. Shifts suggest time of day.
WHEWithin Her Eyes
Natural light only — daylight, golden hour, misty conditions. No theatrical rigging. Weather and time of day shape the mood.
🎵 Aural Setting — music, sound, silence. Composer, instruments, structure.
ATArtificial Things
Opens with wind soundscape + distant violin. Piano glissando (strings plucked inside piano) and musical box sounds in Gliding Trio. Dave's live tenor solo forms the emotional climax. Chimes. Moments of silence.
ALCA Linha Curva
Brazilian percussion by Percossa. Samba rhythms, drum and surdo layers. Live-performance feel. Energy shifts dramatically across sections.
EofEEmancipation of Expressionism
Section 1 electronic swirls + pulsating drum. Section 2 urban hip hop beat. Section 3 'November' by Max Richter. Section 4 'Til Enda' by Ólafur Arnalds building to climax.
InfraInfra
Composed by Max Richter. Everyday noises — muffled speech, train whistle, radio static, morse code. Violin countermelodies. Piano sections. Natural ambient sound.
ShadShadows
Composed by Nick Powell. Shrill, rapid violin in minor key (Daughter's Solo). Low booming piano notes punctuating sections. Piano and violin in unison at the end, softer and slower. Ends in silence.
WHEWithin Her Eyes
Piano score composed by Scott Smith (also co-director). Wind, birds, natural ambient sound from the Welsh landscape. Gentle and unsettling.
💃 Choreographic Content — dance styles, number of dancers, devices used (unison, canon, contact work), key sections.
ATArtificial Things
4 dancers (2 able-bodied, 2 disabled). Contemporary + integrated inclusive practice. Bennett's collaborative approach. Key sections: opening tableau, Gliding Trio, Family Portraits, Dave's Solo.
ALCA Linha Curva
28 dancers. Samba hip isolations, capoeira kicks and dodges, contemporary extensions. Unison in squares, canon across rows, contact work in Battle. Sections: opening unison, Showing Off, Battle, Adage Septet, Skateboards.
EofEEmancipation of Expressionism
10 dancers (5 male, 5 female — Boy Blue Entertainment). Hip hop styles (breaking, popping, locking, waving) fused with contemporary. Ninja Walk, unison, canon, counterpoint.
InfraInfra
12 dancers (6 male, 6 female — Royal Ballet). Classical ballet + contemporary fusion. Duets, counterpoint, brief unison. Restrained, intimate choreography with sudden group release.
ShadShadows
4 dancers (family unit — Mother, Father, Son, Daughter). Contact work, gestural storytelling, Bruce's chain motifs. Pedestrian movement at the ending — 4 slow walks forward.
WHEWithin Her Eyes
2 dancers. Contact work throughout. Female never touches the floor. Long establishing shots → handheld intimate camera. Dance for camera — framing and editing are integral.
Works Explorer — Pick Any Two Works
Tap two works to see them side by side across all 8 features. Tap a third work to replace your first choice.
Question Bank — 10 Exam-Style Comparisons

Ten comparison questions covering every work pairing and feature combination you're likely to face. Each one has a textarea for your attempt and a mark-scheme-style model answer you can reveal. Aim for 4–5 paragraphs — similarities first, then differences.

S — SimilarityD — DifferenceI — InterpretE — Evaluate
Revision Check

Three activities · /15

Work through all three, then submit to see your score.

ACT 1 · /6 Match the comparison connective to its function
Every top-band comparison uses these. Tap a connective, then tap whether it signals a similarity or a difference.
Similarity
Difference
ACT 2 · /4 Spot the mistake — which one caps your answer?
Each sentence below describes a common comparison mistake. Tap the Level ceiling it creates.
ACT 3 · /5 Similarity, Difference, Interpret or Evaluate?
Each extract comes from a mark-scheme exemplar. What comparison move is it doing?
0/15
📸
Take a screenshot of your score now and paste it into your ePortfolio so your teacher can see your progress.

📌 Revisit this — the essentials

Command phrase"Using your knowledge of the similarities and differences…"
FrameworkSimilarities → Differences, with DLIE inside each paragraph
Worst mistakeTwo separate mini-essays instead of comparing
Magic connectivessimilarly · in contrast · whereas · however
Top-band moveMultiple interpretations per shared feature
Time budget~13 minutes · 4–5 paragraphs
Related pages
🎯 Section C · Mini Site 8d

12-Mark Comparison Questions

Two works, one production feature, similarities and differences. The highest-level thinking on the paper — side-by-side analysis across the repertoire.

1
per paper
12
marks
~13
mins suggested

📚 What you'll learn on this page

  • Recognise a comparison question and the six possible linking words (similarities, differences, contrast, enhance, appreciation)
  • Structure your answer using the Similarities → Differences framework with DLIE depth
  • Use comparison connectives (similarly, in contrast, however, whereas) to signpost the examiner through your thinking
  • Compare all six works across 8 key features — costume, lighting, aural, set, intent, stimulus, mood, choreographic content
  • Pick any two works and see them side-by-side in the Works Explorer
  • Work through a bank of 10 exam-style questions with mark-scheme model answers
Exam Technique

A 12-mark comparison question always names two works, one production feature, and asks you to discuss similarities and differences. The wording is almost identical every year:

The standard wording
Standard
Using your knowledge of the similarities and differences in the [feature] used in [Work A] and [Work B], discuss how [feature] is used to enhance our appreciation of these two works. [12 marks]

Three example questions, showing the pattern:

Costume
Using your knowledge of the similarities and differences in the costumes used in Infra and Shadows, discuss how costume is used to enhance our appreciation of these two works.
12 mk
Aural
Using your knowledge of the similarities and differences in the aural setting used in Emancipation of Expressionism and Shadows, discuss how the aural setting is used to enhance our appreciation of these two works.
12 mk
Set
Using your knowledge of the similarities and differences in the staging/set used in Within Her Eyes and Infra, discuss how staging/set is used to enhance our appreciation of these two works. You may refer to props in your answer.
12 mk
👁️
Examiner's EyeYou need to address both works and cover similarities and differences. Answers that only discuss one work in depth, or that only list differences, cannot reach Level 4. The word "discuss" tells you interpretation and evaluation are still expected — this isn't a list.
Comparison Tables — All 6 Works Side by Side

Use these tables as your revision foundation. Pick any feature, see all six works in one place. The spotting similarities and differences is half the work done for any comparison question.

🎯 Choreographic Intention — what the choreographer wanted the work to express. This is often the link point in 12-mark questions.
ATArtificial Things
To explore life's limitations and the resolutions to these. To explore being the subject of other people's gaze.
ALCA Linha Curva
To celebrate Brazilian culture — samba, capoeira, carnival, the way Brazilian men show off, compete and communicate.
EofEEmancipation of Expressionism
Hip hop as a means of emancipation — showing hip hop can be elevated and expressive like any other dance form.
InfraInfra
Emotional life below the surface of city streets — the private turmoil hidden beneath the anonymous public face.
ShadShadows
A small family facing an unknown outside force, inspired by WWII families living in fear of an unseen threat.
WHEWithin Her Eyes
A love story with a twist — exploring loss, dependency, loyalty and grief through intense physical contact.
💡 Stimulus — what inspired the choreographer to make the work. Can be an image, a text, a place, a personal memory, a piece of music.
ATArtificial Things
A snow globe with a figure on a collapsed wheelchair. Paintings by Goran Djurovic (Unknown Secrets). The dancers' own life experiences.
ALCA Linha Curva
Brazilian culture — samba, capoeira, carnival. Galili's experience working with Brazilian dancers.
EofEEmancipation of Expressionism
Kenrick "H2O" Sandy's personal journey in dance. The potential of hip hop as a vehicle for emancipation and expression.
InfraInfra
T.S. Eliot's The Waste Land — the crowd flowing over London Bridge. Also the 2005 London Bombings on the Underground.
ShadShadows
WWII families living in hiding or fleeing — the refugee experience, fear of an unseen external threat.
WHEWithin Her Eyes
A commission brief: A Love Story with a Twist. Cousins' exploration of contact work and physical dependency.
🎭 Mood & Atmosphere — the emotional feeling the audience gets. Often shifts across a work.
ATArtificial Things
Cold, isolated, contemplative → warm, resolved. A sense of melancholy and nostalgia runs throughout.
ALCA Linha Curva
Energetic, joyful, competitive, sensual. High-octane celebration, with quieter moments in the Adage Septet.
EofEEmancipation of Expressionism
Mystical → urban → contemplative → climactic release. Builds from confined to liberated.
InfraInfra
Intimate, raw, melancholy. A sense of private emotion within urban anonymity.
ShadShadows
Fearful, tense, tragic → dignified acceptance. A sense of impending doom lifting into quiet resignation.
WHEWithin Her Eyes
Ethereal, haunting, tender. A sense of something unresolved or otherworldly.
👕 Costume — colour, style, era, material, and how it supports character and intent.
ATArtificial Things
Muted blues, greens and beige with a distinctive streaked dip-dye paint effect. Different eras — Amy's 1960s dress, Laura's 1940s trousers, men's modern-day. Dave's brown jacket recalls his father. Designer: Anna Jones.
ALCA Linha Curva
Men in coloured shorts with metallic discs, bare chests. Women in bright bikini tops and shorts in coral, orange, pink. Vibrant carnival palette.
EofEEmancipation of Expressionism
Functional streetwear — loose trousers, earthy t-shirts in pale blues, black, grey. Hi-top trainers. The typical hip-hop "crew" look, stripped back and minimal.
InfraInfra
Fitted shorts, vests and t-shirts in flesh, black, white and grey. Females in pointe shoes. LED figures on screen wear public overcoats, briefcases, pencil skirts. Designer: Moritz Junge.
ShadShadows
Individual 1940s character costumes — Mother's floral tea dress, Father's collarless shirt and waistcoat, Son's untucked shirt, Daughter's grey skirt and cotton blouse. Oversized overcoats at the end.
WHEWithin Her Eyes
F: sheer cream chiffon blouse buttoned high, skirt, bare feet. Cardigan at start. Top 2 buttons come undone later. M: dark khaki chinos, long-sleeved sweatshirt, khaki boots.
🏛️ Set & Props — the staging environment, scenery, objects used on stage or on screen.
ATArtificial Things
Snow-globe-shaped wooden border on pale grey floor. Vitrine on its side USL filled with snow. Headless mannequin in brown suit on 3 stools. Collapsed wheelchair DSR. Linear pathways of paper snow. Painted backcloth.
ALCA Linha Curva
Bare stage — no scenery. Open space to maximise visibility of 28 dancers. Some props (skateboards) in the Skateboard section.
EofEEmancipation of Expressionism
Minimal black box. A black backdrop that flies out to reveal a white cyclorama in the climactic final section. No other scenery.
InfraInfra
18m LED screen suspended high upstage with white electronic walking figures. Black box below with no other scenery. Set designer: Julian Opie.
ShadShadows
Minimal — table, bench, 2 stools, coat stand USL with worn coats and suitcases from the very start. Black surrounding space.
WHEWithin Her Eyes
No theatrical set. Site-sensitive Welsh landscape — deserted street, open field, forest, heath, quarry, cliff top.
💡 Lighting — colour, intensity, direction, patterns. Supports mood, shape and time of day.
ATArtificial Things
Cold white spots creating snow-globe pools. Cold blue wash in Gliding Trio. Warm amber sidelight SL for Family Portraits. Journey from cold/dark to warm/resolved.
ALCA Linha Curva
49 overhead lights in a 7×7 chequerboard grid in multiple colours, pre-programmed to change. Warm orange sidelighting in Battle. Drops to 7 yellow squares in Adage Septet. Designer: Itzik Galili.
EofEEmancipation of Expressionism
Prominent blue wash from above. White sidelights from SR in Section 2. Theatrical fog catches the blue light. Pale purple cyclorama reveal at the climax.
InfraInfra
3 mid-intensity white pools DS in a horizontal line. 6 rectangles of white light encase 6 duets. Deep blue beams and stark white sidelighting later. Blurred, hazy edges.
ShadShadows
Naturalistic domestic feel. Cold white sidelighting for tense sections, warmer interior lights for family moments. Shifts suggest time of day.
WHEWithin Her Eyes
Natural light only — daylight, golden hour, misty conditions. No theatrical rigging. Weather and time of day shape the mood.
🎵 Aural Setting — music, sound, silence. Composer, instruments, structure.
ATArtificial Things
Opens with wind soundscape + distant violin. Piano glissando (strings plucked inside piano) and musical box sounds in Gliding Trio. Dave's live tenor solo forms the emotional climax. Chimes. Moments of silence.
ALCA Linha Curva
Brazilian percussion by Percossa. Samba rhythms, drum and surdo layers. Live-performance feel. Energy shifts dramatically across sections.
EofEEmancipation of Expressionism
Section 1 electronic swirls + pulsating drum. Section 2 urban hip hop beat. Section 3 'November' by Max Richter. Section 4 'Til Enda' by Ólafur Arnalds building to climax.
InfraInfra
Composed by Max Richter. Everyday noises — muffled speech, train whistle, radio static, morse code. Violin countermelodies. Piano sections. Natural ambient sound.
ShadShadows
Composed by Nick Powell. Shrill, rapid violin in minor key (Daughter's Solo). Low booming piano notes punctuating sections. Piano and violin in unison at the end, softer and slower. Ends in silence.
WHEWithin Her Eyes
Piano score composed by Scott Smith (also co-director). Wind, birds, natural ambient sound from the Welsh landscape. Gentle and unsettling.
💃 Choreographic Content — dance styles, number of dancers, devices used (unison, canon, contact work), key sections.
ATArtificial Things
4 dancers (2 able-bodied, 2 disabled). Contemporary + integrated inclusive practice. Bennett's collaborative approach. Key sections: opening tableau, Gliding Trio, Family Portraits, Dave's Solo.
ALCA Linha Curva
28 dancers. Samba hip isolations, capoeira kicks and dodges, contemporary extensions. Unison in squares, canon across rows, contact work in Battle. Sections: opening unison, Showing Off, Battle, Adage Septet, Skateboards.
EofEEmancipation of Expressionism
10 dancers (5 male, 5 female — Boy Blue Entertainment). Hip hop styles (breaking, popping, locking, waving) fused with contemporary. Ninja Walk, unison, canon, counterpoint.
InfraInfra
12 dancers (6 male, 6 female — Royal Ballet). Classical ballet + contemporary fusion. Duets, counterpoint, brief unison. Restrained, intimate choreography with sudden group release.
ShadShadows
4 dancers (family unit — Mother, Father, Son, Daughter). Contact work, gestural storytelling, Bruce's chain motifs. Pedestrian movement at the ending — 4 slow walks forward.
WHEWithin Her Eyes
2 dancers. Contact work throughout. Female never touches the floor. Long establishing shots → handheld intimate camera. Dance for camera — framing and editing are integral.
Works Explorer — Pick Any Two Works
Tap two works to see them side by side across all 8 features. Tap a third work to replace your first choice.
Question Bank — 10 Exam-Style Comparisons

Ten comparison questions covering every work pairing and feature combination you're likely to face. Each one has a textarea for your attempt and a mark-scheme-style model answer you can reveal. Aim for 4–5 paragraphs — similarities first, then differences.

S — SimilarityD — DifferenceI — InterpretE — Evaluate
Revision Check

Three activities · /15

Work through all three, then submit to see your score.

ACT 1 · /6 Match the comparison connective to its function
Every top-band comparison uses these. Tap a connective, then tap whether it signals a similarity or a difference.
Similarity
Difference
ACT 2 · /4 Spot the mistake — which one caps your answer?
Each sentence below describes a common comparison mistake. Tap the Level ceiling it creates.
ACT 3 · /5 Similarity, Difference, Interpret or Evaluate?
Each extract comes from a mark-scheme exemplar. What comparison move is it doing?
0/15
📸
Take a screenshot of your score now and paste it into your ePortfolio so your teacher can see your progress.

📌 Revisit this — the essentials

Command phrase"Using your knowledge of the similarities and differences…"
FrameworkSimilarities → Differences, with DLIE inside each paragraph
Worst mistakeTwo separate mini-essays instead of comparing
Magic connectivessimilarly · in contrast · whereas · however
Top-band moveMultiple interpretations per shared feature
Time budget~13 minutes · 4–5 paragraphs
Related pages